Τετάρτη 8 Ιουνίου 2016


The Psychology Sessions: Modern Trends in Psychology

  

Does your handwriting say anything about your personality?


 


Graphology: A pseudoscience that claims to assess personality, social, and occupational attributes based on a person's distinctive handwriting, doodles, and drawing style (Hockenbury & Hockenbury, 2013). 

The basic concept of graphology is that handwriting reveals human temperament, personality traits, intelligence and reasoning ability. In addition to that, graphologists claim that they can accurately evaluate a job applicant's integrity , reliability, leadership potential, ability to work within a team or, even, flexibilty. 

Since the '90s, handwriting analysis has become quite popular throughout North America and Europe: back in 1996, in the United States, there were over 30 graphology societies, each promoting its own specific methods of analysing handwriting (Beyerstein, 1996). According to Scanlon and Mauro (1992), many institutions such as the F.B.I. and the U.S. State Department have consulted graphologists to assess the handwriting of people, who mail death threats to government officials.

Graphology is especially popular in the business world. Thousands of American companies, including Sears, U.S. Steel, and Bendix, have used graphology to assist in hiring new employees (Basil, 1991; Taylor & Sackheim, 1988). The use of graphology in hiring and promotions is even more widespread in Europe. According to one estimate, over 80 percent of European companies use graphology in personnel matters (Greasley, 2000; see Simner & Goffi n, 2003). 




A Case Study of Graphology (Hockenbury & Hockenbury, 2013)

In 1992, a study by Anthony Edwards and Peter Armitage examined the ability of graphologists to distinguish among people in three different groups: 1) Successful vs unsuccessful secretaries, 2) Successful business entrepreuners vs librarians and bank clerks, and 3) Actors/actresses vs monks and nuns. During their study, Edwards and Armitage collaborated with leading graphologists and incorporated their suggestions into their study design, since, the graphologists preapproved the study's format and stated that it was a valid test of graphology. Apart from that, the graphologists, also, predicted that they would have a high rate of success (even 100%) in discriminating among the people in each group. The three groups - as mentioned above - represented a combined total of 170 participants, who had to mention their age, sex, and hand preference. The assignment for each person was to produce 20 lines of spontaneous handwriting on a neutral topic, which would be evaluated by four leading graphologists. Additionally, the handwriting samples would be evaluated by four ordinary people with no formal training (Untrained assessors), and the typewritten transcripts of the handwriting samples would be, also, evaluated by four psychologists, who would assess the content of the transcripts.

When the assessment was completed, the study results turned out to be quite ambiguous: 
  • Compared to the untrained assessors and psychologists, the graphologists fared quite well: (63-67%) vs (53-70%) and (52-56%), respectively.       
  •  However, the graphologists didn't succeed in reaching the nearly perfect level of accuracy they predicted: especially, in the case of Good-Bad Secretaries, the 'untrained assessors' outperformed the graphologists (70% vs 67%). 
  • Overall, the inexperienced assessors achieved a success rate of 59% correct, whereas, the professional graphologists a slightly better success rate of 65%. Since the difference was narrow and the expectations of the graphologists were quite high, the question whether graphology can assess personality, still, remains unanswered.     
Further, hundreds of other research studies have cast similar doubts on the ability of graphology to identify personality traits, predict job performance or indicate certain competences (Dean, 1992; Furnham, 2008, etc.). In a global review of the research findings and evidence, the notable psychologist Barry Bernstein concluded that, since graphologists have failed to demonstrate the validity and reliability of their field for identifying personality traits and talents or predicting job performance, then, graphology cannot be called a legitimate and scientific means of assessing personality; it is, really, a pseudoscience.
Last year, I attended a graphology seminar. I have to say that graphology has a long way in order to prove its 'scientific nature'. However, I must admit that the graphologist made some interesting points concerning the personality traits and talents of the participants including myself, after evaluating our handwriting. Graphologists must find ways to prove their field's validity since most people and scientists can't understand or find the scientific basis of graphology e.g. why the way you write the letter G indicates a certain personality trait? To be fair, though, graphologists could bring interesting information about human personality 'on the table', if only they could prove its validity and reliability!     




References

 Hockenbury Don H. & Hockenbury Sandra E. (2013). Psychology (6th edition). New York: Worth Publishers.
 Beyerstein, Barry L. (1996). Graphology. In Gordon Stein (Ed.), The encyclopedia
of the paranormal. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.
 Basil, Robert. (1991). Graphology and personality: “Let the buyer beware.”
In Kendrick Frazier (Ed.), The hundredth monkey and other paradigms
of the paranormal. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.

Simner, Marvin L.; & Goffin, Richard D. (2003, December). A position
statement by the International Graphonomics Society on the use of graphology
in personnel selection testing. International Journal of Testing, 3(4), 353–364.

Furnham, Adam. (2008). Personality and intelligence at work: Exploring
and explaining individual differences at work. London: Routledge.

Picture Source Links 

https://www.cartoonstock.com/directory/a/application_form.asp,

https://gr.pinterest.com/pin/156992736979879251/,

https://eleonoradegano.wordpress.com/tag/graphology/,

https://gr.pinterest.com/desicthy/a-guide-to-graphology/.

Tim Voridis

Organisational Psychologist/Consultant - Communication and Personality Specialist

'Innovation for a brighter future'.

 

Παρασκευή 27 Μαΐου 2016


The Psychology Sessions: Modern Trends in Psychology

   

Is introversion a misunderstood personality trait?



The American president who is most consistently ranked number one of all time is .... Abraham Lincoln (David Myers, 2014). Abraham Lincoln was introverted,even, sometimes, slow in decision making, but very effective and innovative. Is it really an extrovert's world or is introversion a misunderstood personality trait?

Before answering the question, let's remember some important facts:

  • Whether a person is an extrovert or introvert depends on how he/she directs their libido and, generally, their life force (Robert Stewart, 1998).  
  •  The extroverts' attention is directed to other people and the world, producing an outgoing personality that enjoys company and likes to share life with others - albeit on a more superficial level.
  •  On the contrary, introverted people are fascinated by ideas, are more solitary and self-reliant, often, looking inward to the world of the unconscious - however, their friendships are, usually, fewer, but deeper.
  •  Carl Jung's pioneering model of introversion-extroversion has influenced, significantly, fields such as recruitment and selection, human resource management, public relations, marketing, training, education, mass media and, generally, our everyday life. 
  •  Practically, every person has both introvert and extrovert tendencies, however, one or the other usually predominates!

Famous Swedish actress-diva, Greta Garbo (1905-1990) was a classic introvert, even though, she made a successful career in, maybe, the most over-exposed profession. In 1941, she decided to stop acting by saying the timeless quote: 'I want to be left alone'.  

As David Myers (2014) clearly points out, psychologists describe personality, but they don't advise which traits people should or should not have. However, Society does this: western cultures, often, consider extraversion as one of the most significant personality traits. Being introverted means that you don't have the 'right stuff' (David Myers, 2014: Cain, 2012).

 Just think about superheroes such as Superman, who is bold, energetic, strong and outspoken, whereas, his alter ego, Clark Kent, is calm, mild-mannered and writes for a living. One could definitely say that the message is that if you want people to admire you of your strength and heroism, you must show them that you're an extrovert. Another source of examples of successful extroverts is TV and, especially, TV series such as Mad Men: Donald Draper, the successful, charismatic and dominant advertising executive is a classic extrovert. Therefore, the crucial questions are: a) Does extraversion lead to success?, b) Why do western cultures favor extraversion? and c) Can western societies, really, understand what introversion is?.

The first thought that most people have is that introversion, shyness and a somewhat reserved attitude are interlinked, when practically, they are not. If you notice introverted people, you will find out that they tend to seek low levels of stimulation and arousal from their environment or surroundings, because they are very sensitive and easily affected. According to one classic study, introverted people, even, have greater taste sensitivity: when given lemon juice, introverted people salivated more than extraverted people (David Myers, 2014: Corcoran, 1964). On the contrary, shy people remain quiet, distant or, even, withdrawn because they fear negative evaluation or rejection by others.      



Apart from that, most people perceive introversion as a barrier to success, however, introverts can experience success or achievement as much as extroverts. Introverted leaders can even outperform extraverted leaders because they show greater receptiveness when their employees voice their ideas, challenge existing norms, and take charge (David Myers, 2014: Grant et al. 2011). 

Susan Cain, the author  of “Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking”
 wrote an article on the New Times in September 2012 mentioning the fact that effective leadership or success is not correlated with extraversion or introversion, and that on the long list of attributes of a successful president - or of any leader- an outgoing persona is low on the list. Therefore, she concludes that: 1) introverted leaders possess an innate caution that may be more valuable than we realise and 2) regardless of an extraverted or introverted personality, the charisma of ideas and vision is what matters the most.

Another factor, which plays an integral part in evaluating extroversion-introversion is Cross-Cultural Differences, that is Western Cultures vs Eastern or Asian Cultures. As stated above, cultures such as the American tends to reward or appreciate more extroversion because the USA is a culture of 'external' personality and aggressive/winning negotiation tactics. On the contrary, other cultures such as Japan and India prize introversion as people are valued for their "inner selves and their moral rectitude".        

Adding to that, it is important for all people, societies and cultures to understand that introversion should not be treated suspiciously or unfairly: People who need to be alone or have a quiet break from a loud party or event are not strange, weak or incapable of great achievements. They, simply, know how to pick an environment where they can thrive, therefore, it is crucial for extroverts to realise that not everyone needs the high levels of stimulation that they do, and that it is not a crime to unwind and cool down (David Myers, 2014).
   

According to Huffington Post, this is an indicative list of notable introverts: Eleanor Roosevelt, J. K. Rowling, Bill Gates, Carl Gustav Jung, Albert Einstein, Mahatma Gandhi, Audrey Hepburn, Warren Buffett, George Stephanopoulos, Barack Obama, Mark Zuckerberg, Marilyn Monroe, Beyonce Knowles, Steven Spielberg, Michelle Pfeiffer, Angelina Jolie, Johnny Depp, James Dean, Clint Eastwood, John Lennon and many others. 


"I want to exist from my own force, like the sun, which gives light and does not suck light"

Carl Gustav Jung.


References

Robert Stewart (1997), Ideas that shaped our world: Understanding the great concepts of then and now, London: Marshall Publishing.

David G. Myers and C. Nathan DeWall (2014), Psychology in everyday life, 3rd edition, New York: Worth Publishers. 

 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/16/opinion/sunday/introverts-make-great-leaders-too.html?_r=0.

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraversion_and_introversion.

 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/08/15/famous-introverts_n_3733400.html. 

https://gr.pinterest.com/biljanaf7/carl-gustav-jung/. 


Picture Source Links

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/240379698838316037/, 
 http://quotesgram.com/famous-quotes-about-introverts/, 
http://robsiej.deviantart.com/art/Greta-Garbo-503402914, 
https://pixabay.com/el/photos/word%20art/.



Tim Voridis

Organisational Psychologist/Consultant - Communication and Personality Specialist

'Innovation for a brighter future'.

Σάββατο 21 Μαΐου 2016

Effective teamwork (2016 revised and updated)

 

Teamwork for effective organisations (2001)

Creating the atmosphere
↓
Leader→1. Vision- goal→ team members

a) Inspiration-Motivation(shared-realistic goal)
b) Planning the company’s goal-realization
c) Going along with the goal (reflection)
d) Initiative-dialogue

Common vision= shared victory and shared defeat





2. Synergy-co-ordination-co-operation


a) Group Dynamics

b) Information exchange (trust-team philosophy

c) Team roles (Belbin)-relationships within the team- respect-harmony

d) Self-confidence

 

3. Empowerment-Development-Competencies


a) Technical and interpersonal skills-use of resources

b) Commitment-responsibility-accountability

 c) Effective HRM strategies-The Person-centered approach (Carl      

                                      Rogers’ theory)





 4. Flexibility-exploration-decision making

a) Evaluation of options
b) Constructive controversy-‘synthesis’ (Hegel’s philosophical   
                          theory)-consensus
c) Probing-listening



5. Looking for future improvement

a) Monitoring (evaluation of the present situation)
b) Correction of mistakes-conflict resolution
 
Teamwork is an ongoing journey, not a destination!



References-Bibliographical sources

Dean Tjosvold, Team Organization: An Enduring Competitive Advantage (Wiley Series in Industrial and Organizational Psychology), 1st edition, 1992, John Wiley & Sons

 Nicky Hayes, Successful Team Management (Essential Business Psychology), 1st edition, 1996, Cengage Learning EMEA

Adrian Furnham, The Psychology of Behaviour at Work: The Individual in the Organization, 1st edition, 1999, Psychology Press. 




Σάββατο 26 Μαρτίου 2016

Analytical Psychology: Archetypes in dreams: Was Carl Jung ahead of its time? Are fairy tales based on archetypal characters?



The fairy tale of Snow White can be found all over the world with slight variations, a fact which shows the universal popularity of myths and fairy tales. Carl Jung attributed this vast popularity to their clever use of archetypal characters (e.g. Snow White represents the positive human qualities, whereas, the Queen the negative and harmful: Good-Evil).

Carl Jung beleived that the archetypes are of significant importance in the interpretation of dreams, since dreams are a form of dialogue between the conscious self (ego) and the eternal (the collective unconscious), and archetypes operate as symbols within the dream, facilitating the dialogue.


The archetypes have specific meanings in the context of dreams: the Wise Old Man or Woman may be represented in a dream by a parent, teacher or doctor - it indicates those who offer guidance, direction, wisdom, and, usually, act as mentors or protectors. And lest the ego grow too large, it is kept in check by the appearance of the Trickster, a playful archetype that exposes the dreamer's vulnerabilities and plays jokes, preventing the individual from taking himself and his desires too seriously(Catherine Collin, 2012).

According to Carl Jung (1875-1961), most of what we, generally, attribute to deliberate, reasoned, conscious thinking is, actually, being guided by unconscious activity, especially, the organizing forms of the archetypes. The archetypes exist in our minds before conscious thought, and can, therefore, have a powerful impact on our perception of experience(Philip G. Zimbardo, 1997).

Jung's work on archetypes influenced immensely the fields of psychology and spirituality, and his archetypes are so widespread that can be easily identified in films, literature, pop and rock music, or cultural forms that attempt to portray universal characters.




Bibliographical Sources

Catherine Collin, Voula Grand, Nigel Benson, Merrin Lazyan, Joannah Ginsburg and Marcus Weeks (2012), The Psychology Book: Big Ideas Simply explained, London: Dorling Kindersley Limited.
Philip G. Zimbardo and Ann L. Weber (1997). Psychology, 2nd edition. New York: Longman. 


Tim Voridis

Organisational Psychologist/Consultant - Communication and Personality Specialist
'Innovation for a brighter future'



Παρασκευή 25 Μαρτίου 2016

The theory of the 4 humours through the years!



The Psychology Sessions 2

From Embedocles to Carl Jung and Modern Psychology!

Key points, modern applications and further suggestions for the the 21st Century (Previously Posted Parts 1+2+3)!!!




 

  • According to Empedocles (c.495-435 BCE), the Greek philosopher, the world is a combination of four elements: earth (cold and dry), air (warm and wet), fire (warm and dry) and water (cold and wet).
  • Hippocrates (460-370 BCE), the 'Father of Medicine', developed a medical model based on these elements, attributing their qualities to four fluids within the body ('humours') (Catherine Collin, 2012). 
  • Galen (c.129-c.201 CE) expanded the theory of the four humours into one of personality connecting the levels of the humours in the body to emotional or behavioural inclinations ('temperaments'). The four temperaments (sanguine, phlegmatic, choleric, melancholic) are based on the balance of the humours in the body.


  • Imbalance in the humours determines personality type  and if one of the humours develops excessively, the corresponding type begins to dominate e.g. The sanguine personality type has too much blood (sanguis in Latin) and is, usually, optimistic, outspoken, assertive, sociable, warm-hearted and confident but, at times, can be selfish and eccentric.
  • The melancholic type, who has an excess of black bile is characterised by poetic and artistic leanings, which are, often, accompanied by sadness, fear, aloofness and introspection.
  • The choleric type, who suffers from excess yellow bile, is, usually, fiery, energetic, passionate, however,  when threatened, this type can become irritable, excitable, aggressive and dominant.
  • The phlegmatic type suffers from excess phlegm and is quiet, rational, supportive, kind and consistent, but, on the negative side, can become sluggish, slow, shy and apathetic.
  • The theory of the four humours was believed for centuries, up through the Middle Ages, although it has not held up to modern scrutiny (Philip G. Zimbardo, 2002).
  • However, a modern echo of the theory meant to be seen, later, on 20th century theories of personality such as Gordon Allport's trait approach (1937) and, especially, Hans Eysenck's personality model (1973).




  • Although the theory of the four humours is no longer part of Psychology, the idea that many physical and mental illnesses are connected forms the basis of some modern methods of psychotherapy. Additionally, as stated above, humourism influenced modern psychologists and helped personality typology and trait theories to emerge.
  • In 1921, Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Gustav Jung was the first to introduce the terms 'introvert' and 'extrovert' (Fundamental Attitudes) in his book 'Psychological Types': 'Extraverts' are, usually, outgoing, sociable, assertive and talkative people, whereas, 'Introverts' tend to be more quiet, shy, withdrawn and cautious, however, they do not necessarily lack social skills. They are more inclined to direct their interests to ideas than to social events, because they feel more comfortable being alone compared to the 'Extroverts' (Steven L. McShane, 2005). According to Jung, the psychic energy flow of the 'Extroverts' is outward, whereas, the psychic energy of the 'Introverts' is inward. 
  • Dominant Functions: Further, Jung suggested that everyone has particular preferences for collecting, processing and acquiring information(Sensing or Intuition) and judging or deciding on action (Thinking or Feeling). Sensing Types depend on their five senses and use an organised structure in order to acquire information, whereas, Intuitive Types rely more on subjective evidence, personal intuition and sheer inspiration. Thinking Types weigh the evidence more objectively and less emotionally compared to the Feeling Types,  who make choices according to their personal values. Examples of suggestive occupations matching the Eight Jungian Types (Feist and Feist, 2009):
  • Introverted Thinking: Philosopher, Inventor, Theoretical Scientist.
  • Extraverted Thinking: Research Scientist, Accountant, Mathematician
  • Introverted Feeling: Psychologist, Social Worker, Physician.
  • Extraverted Feeling: Real Estate Appraisers, Teacher, Movie Critic, Lawyer.
  • Introverted Sensing: Classical Musician, Chef, Artist.
  • Extraverted Sensing: Proofreader, Popular Musician, Marketer
  • Introverted Intuition: Network Specialist, Scientist, Healer.
  • Extraverted Intuition: Religious Reformer, Manager, Journalist.     

References

  • Catherine Collin, Voula Grand, Nigel Benson, Merrin Lazyan, Joannah Ginsburg and Marcus Weeks (2012), The Psychology Book: Big Ideas Simply explained, London: Dorling Kindersley Limited.

  • Richard J. Gerrig and Philip G. Zimbardo (2002), Psychology and Life, 7th edition, Boston: Allyn and Bacon.

  • Steven L. McShane and Mary Ann Von Glinow (2005), Organizational Behaviour: Emerging Realities for the Worklplace Revolution, 3rd International Edition, New York: McGraw-Hill.

  • Feist and Feist (2009), Theories of Personality, 7th Edition, New York: McGraw-Hill.



Tim Voridis

Organisational Psychologist/Consultant - Communication and Personality Specialist
'Innovation for a brighter future'.